No cover yet

All-Star Comics

#36

August-September 1947 · 0.10 USD · 52 pages


Synopsis

Calvin Stymes invites five lifelong friends and fraternity brothers out to a western ranch, and, as they sit around the campfire, he recounts the legend of the dried-out stream-bed they were camping in. Called Koehaha, or "Stream of Ruthlessness," it runs once every 100 years. Strangely, those who "drown" in it don't really die, but neither do they come back to life, for the water washes away a man's better nature and replaces it with a ruthless nature. Each man explains what he might do with a criminal nature, then they all go to bed. Stymes moves onto the river bank while the others drown.

Notes

On-sale date from copyright registration.

Scripter Gardner Fox reports writing and being paid for the unpublished JSA tale, "The Men of Magnifica," in November of 1945, he believes for All-Star #38. Clearly, the basic structure and other elements of that story are found in the "5 Drowned Men." Thus this issue's story is most likely a drastically revised script by Julius Schwartz, with some re-writing by Robert Kanigher, of that story.

Reprinted in

Credits

Script
Julius Schwartz, Robert Kanigher, Ted Udall, Harry Lampert
Pencils
Irwin Hasen, Lee Elias, Joe Kubert, Frank Harry, Harry Lampert, Ed Wheelan
Inks
Irwin Hasen, Lee Elias, Joe Kubert, Frank Harry, John Belfi, Harry Lampert, Ed Wheelan
Letters
Harry Lampert
Editor
Sheldon Mayer
Original plot
Gardner Fox, Sheldon Mayer
See notes
Irwin Hasen, John Belfi
Story editor, uncredited
Julius Schwartz

Ratings

On eBay now

Checking…